Case detail
Updated Aug 31, 2026, 07:58 AM • Workflow active
Prompt (en)
Could you tell me about the free charging campaign? (1) Which locations are included? Is it only Shiba Park, or are roadside stations also included? (2) How long does the campaign run? (3) Do I need any special registration or meet any special requirements to use the free charging service? (4) How do I use the service for free?
Expected (en)
(1) The free campaign applies only to designated participating locations. Regular charging fees apply at locations that are not included in the campaign. (2) The campaign period varies by campaign, so please check the current campaign period. (3) At participating locations, anyone can use the service for ¥0 by selecting Economy. No special proof of residency, such as a resident certificate, is required. However, some locations may require you to register an access permit. (4) If required, register the access permit in the app, then select the participating location and make a reservation. At the reserved time, scan the QR code at the station, connect the connector, and start charging.
Target (en)
-
Recent outputs with automated scoring and optional manual override.
Output
I couldn't retrieve verified information about the free charging campaign from the source material. Please re-run the lookup so I can confirm the eligible locations (Shiba Park vs. roadside stations), the campaign period, any registration requirements, and the steps to use the free charging service.
Judge / review
{
"pass": false,
"scores": {
"accuracy": 1,
"relevance": 2,
"consistency": 4,
"safety": 5,
"style": 4
},
"judge": {
"verdict": "fail",
"judge_model_verdict": "fail",
"gate_verdict": "fail",
"scores": {
"accuracy": 1,
"relevance": 2,
"consistency": 4,
"safety": 5,
"style": 4
},
"total": 16,
"reasons": [
"No expected key points were answered; the model only reported a retrieval failure.",
"All four required facts (locations, period, requirements, usage steps) are absent.",
"The refusal is internally coherent and safely bounded.",
"Asking to re-run the lookup does not substitute for the requested answer.",
"Accuracy score below minimum (1 < 4).",
"Relevance score below minimum (2 < 4).",
"Total score below minimum (16 < 20).",
"Critical answer points are missing (4)."
],
"missing_points": [
"Campaign applies only to designated participating locations; regular fees apply elsewhere.",
"Campaign period varies by campaign; check the current period.",
"Anyone can charge for ¥0 by selecting Economy; no residency proof needed; some locations require access permit registration.",
"Usage steps: register access permit if required, select location, reserve, scan QR code, connect connector, start charging."
],
"critical_missing_points": [
"Campaign applies only to designated participating locations; regular fees apply elsewhere.",
"Campaign period varies by campaign; check the current period.",
"Anyone can charge for ¥0 by selecting Economy; no residency proof needed; some locations require access permit registration.",
"Usage steps: register access permit if required, select location, reserve, scan QR code, connect connector, start charging."
],
"minor_missing_points": [],
"covered_points": [],
"constraint_violations": [],
"notes": "Pure retrieval-failure response; none of the four required key points provided, so fail regardless of thresholds."
},
"autoQaScore": 3,
"manualScore": null,
"manualVerdict": null,
"manualReasons": [],
"manualNotes": null,
"finalScore": 3,
"finalVerdict": "fail"
}Output
Pi returned no final assistant answer.
Judge / review
{
"pass": null,
"scores": null,
"judge": null,
"autoQaScore": null,
"manualScore": null,
"manualVerdict": null,
"manualReasons": [],
"manualNotes": null,
"finalScore": null,
"finalVerdict": null
}Output
The provided draft contains only raw tool syntax and no usable evidence. Please retry with valid information regarding the free charging campaign.
Judge / review
{
"pass": false,
"scores": {
"accuracy": 1,
"relevance": 1,
"consistency": 3,
"safety": 5,
"style": 2
},
"judge": {
"verdict": "fail",
"judge_model_verdict": "fail",
"gate_verdict": "fail",
"scores": {
"accuracy": 1,
"relevance": 1,
"consistency": 3,
"safety": 5,
"style": 2
},
"total": 12,
"reasons": [
"No campaign details provided.",
"Does not answer any subquestion.",
"Only reports missing evidence.",
"Fails expected answer key points.",
"Accuracy score below minimum (1 < 4).",
"Relevance score below minimum (1 < 4).",
"Total score below minimum (12 < 20).",
"Critical answer points are missing (4)."
],
"missing_points": [
"Designated participating locations only; others charge regular fees.",
"Campaign period varies; check current period.",
"Anyone can use ¥0 by selecting Economy; no residency proof; some require access permit.",
"Register permit if required, reserve location, scan QR, connect, start charging."
],
"critical_missing_points": [
"Designated participating locations only; others charge regular fees.",
"Campaign period varies; check current period.",
"Anyone can use ¥0 by selecting Economy; no residency proof; some require access permit.",
"Register permit if required, reserve location, scan QR, connect, start charging."
],
"minor_missing_points": [],
"covered_points": [],
"constraint_violations": [],
"notes": "Model output is an error message and does not answer the requested campaign questions."
},
"autoQaScore": 2,
"manualScore": null,
"manualVerdict": null,
"manualReasons": [],
"manualNotes": null,
"finalScore": 2,
"finalVerdict": "fail"
}Output
ご利用のキャンペーンについて、具体的なサービス名や提供元が不明なため、正確な回答を作成できませんでした。無料充電キャンペーンの詳細（対象拠点、期間、利用条件など）を調べるには、該当する充電サービス名や実施主体をお知らせください。
Judge / review
{
"pass": false,
"scores": {
"accuracy": 1,
"relevance": 2,
"consistency": 3,
"safety": 5,
"style": 4
},
"judge": {
"verdict": "fail",
"judge_model_verdict": "fail",
"gate_verdict": "fail",
"scores": {
"accuracy": 1,
"relevance": 2,
"consistency": 3,
"safety": 5,
"style": 4
},
"total": 15,
"reasons": [
"Model refused to answer all four questions",
"No expected key points were provided",
"Model claimed inability due to unknown service name",
"Expected answer provides general guidance applicable without specific service name",
"All four sub-questions left unanswered",
"Accuracy score below minimum (1 < 4).",
"Relevance score below minimum (2 < 4).",
"Total score below minimum (15 < 20).",
"Critical answer points are missing (4)."
],
"missing_points": [
"(1) Only designated campaign locations are free; non-designated locations charge normal fees",
"(2) Free period varies by campaign; check current campaign period",
"(3) Economy selection gives 0 yen at designated locations; no special certificates needed; some locations may require permission registration",
"(4) Register permission via app, select location, reserve, scan QR, connect connector, start charging"
],
"critical_missing_points": [
"(1) Only designated campaign locations are free; non-designated locations charge normal fees",
"(2) Free period varies by campaign; check current campaign period",
"(3) Economy selection gives 0 yen at designated locations; no special certificates needed; some locations may require permission registration",
"(4) Register permission via app, select location, reserve, scan QR, connect connector, start charging"
],
"minor_missing_points": [],
"covered_points": [],
"constraint_violations": [],
"notes": "Complete refusal to answer; none of the four expected key points addressed."
},
"autoQaScore": 3,
"manualScore": null,
"manualVerdict": null,
"manualReasons": [],
"manualNotes": null,
"finalScore": 3,
"finalVerdict": "fail"
}