Output

The draft contained only tool markup, so the fee details could not be verified. Please provide the source content again, and I will restate the non-First member usage fees and the cost to charge an Outlander accurately.

Judge / review

{
  "pass": false,
  "scores": {
    "accuracy": 1,
    "relevance": 2,
    "consistency": 2,
    "safety": 5,
    "style": 3
  },
  "judge": {
    "verdict": "fail",
    "judge_model_verdict": "fail",
    "gate_verdict": "fail",
    "scores": {
      "accuracy": 1,
      "relevance": 2,
      "consistency": 2,
      "safety": 5,
      "style": 3
    },
    "total": 13,
    "reasons": [
      "No fee information provided; answer only reports an internal draft/tool issue.",
      "All required rate key points (65/70/75 yen per kWh) are absent.",
      "Pay-as-you-go billing by actual kWh is not mentioned.",
      "Explanation that exact Outlander total cannot be quoted is missing.",
      "Support article link is missing.",
      "Response deflects responsibility to the user instead of answering.",
      "Accuracy score below minimum (1 < 4).",
      "Relevance score below minimum (2 < 4).",
      "Total score below minimum (13 < 20).",
      "Critical answer points are missing (4)."
    ],
    "missing_points": [
      "General-member rates: 65 yen (Economy), 70 yen (Regular), 75 yen (Premium) per kWh",
      "Billed pay-as-you-go by actual kWh consumed",
      "Exact Outlander total cannot be quoted because output varies by vehicle and conditions",
      "Link to Pricing & PowerX First support article for details"
    ],
    "critical_missing_points": [
      "General-member rates: 65 yen (Economy), 70 yen (Regular), 75 yen (Premium) per kWh",
      "Billed pay-as-you-go by actual kWh consumed",
      "Exact Outlander total cannot be quoted because output varies by vehicle and conditions",
      "Link to Pricing & PowerX First support article for details"
    ],
    "minor_missing_points": [],
    "covered_points": [],
    "constraint_violations": [],
    "notes": "Answer contains no substantive content; only a request to re-provide source material. Complete omission of all key points."
  },
  "autoQaScore": 3,
  "manualScore": null,
  "manualVerdict": null,
  "manualReasons": [],
  "manualNotes": null,
  "finalScore": 3,
  "finalVerdict": "fail"
}

Output

申し訳ございませんが、出典情報を取得できなかったため、First（ファースト）の非会員利用料金およびアウトランダーの充電料金を正確にご案内することができません。誤った料金をお伝えすることを避けるため、運営元の公式サイトまたはカスタマーサポートへのご確認をお願いいたします。情報を取得できましたら、改めてご案内いたします。

Judge / review

{
  "pass": false,
  "scores": {
    "accuracy": 1,
    "relevance": 2,
    "consistency": 4,
    "safety": 5,
    "style": 5
  },
  "judge": {
    "verdict": "fail",
    "judge_model_verdict": "fail",
    "gate_verdict": "fail",
    "scores": {
      "accuracy": 1,
      "relevance": 2,
      "consistency": 4,
      "safety": 5,
      "style": 5
    },
    "total": 17,
    "reasons": [
      "回答は取得失敗を理由とする謝罪のみで、期待回答の料金情報を一切含まない",
      "一般会員の1kWhあたり料金（Economy 65円、Regular 70円、Premium 75円）が欠落",
      "従量課金制である旨の説明が欠落",
      "出力は車種・環境により異なり合計金額は一概に言えないという注意点が欠落",
      "参照リンクが提供されていない",
      "誤情報を避ける姿勢は安全だが、回答として不成立",
      "Accuracy score below minimum (1 < 4).",
      "Relevance score below minimum (2 < 4).",
      "Total score below minimum (17 < 20).",
      "Critical answer points are missing (3)."
    ],
    "missing_points": [
      "一般会員料金：1kWhあたりEconomy 65円、Regular 70円、Premium 75円",
      "従量課金制で実際の充電電力量に応じて課金される旨",
      "出力は車種や環境により異なるため合計金額は一概に提示できない旨",
      "料金・PowerX First詳細のサポートページURL"
    ],
    "critical_missing_points": [
      "一般会員料金：1kWhあたりEconomy 65円、Regular 70円、Premium 75円",
      "従量課金制で実際の充電電力量に応じて課金される旨",
      "出力は車種や環境により異なるため合計金額は一概に提示できない旨"
    ],
    "minor_missing_points": [
      "料金・PowerX First詳細のサポートページURL"
    ],
    "covered_points": [
      "丁寧な日本語の謝罪と公式サイト・サポートへの確認案内"
    ],
    "constraint_violations": [],
    "notes": "検索失敗による回答拒否。安全・文体は良好だが必須の料金情報が全て欠落しfail。"
  },
  "autoQaScore": 3,
  "manualScore": null,
  "manualVerdict": null,
  "manualReasons": [],
  "manualNotes": null,
  "finalScore": 3,
  "finalVerdict": "fail"
}

Output

Non‑First (general) member charging fees

PowerX general use has no monthly fee and is metered pay‑as‑you‑go on the actual electricity delivered, with three menus that differ only in renewable‑energy share (not charging speed):

- Economy – ¥65 per kWh (site's own power contract; renewable share varies)
- Regular – ¥70 per kWh (approx. 70% renewable)
- Premium – ¥75 per kWh (100% renewable, highest environmental value)

Sources: /sources/en/runbooks/charging-use.md:105, /sources/en/runbooks/billing.md:46, /sources/en/reference/membership.md:149 ("Regular Use … Price per kWh ¥65~", no monthly fee).

General-use conditions: booking is day‑of only (from about 30 minutes ahead) with a 30‑minute maximum slot, and up to 150 kW output (some sites currently capped at 120 kW) — /sources/en/reference/membership.md:150-165.

Charging an Outlander

An exact yen total for an Outlander can't be quoted, because the bill is (kWh actually charged) × (menu unit price), and the kWh delivered depends on your battery size, starting state of charge, temperature, and the output the car accepts at that charger. That's also the official guidance position in the runbook for this exact question (/sources/en/runbooks/charging-use.md:105).

What you can do is apply the unit price to the kWh figure shown for your session — for example, 20 kWh would be about ¥1,300 on Economy, ¥1,400 on Regular, or ¥1,500 on Premium. Note the workspace does not contain an Outlander battery‑capacity or typical‑session figure, so I can't responsibly state a full‑charge cost.

Two related points:
- Charging speed is identical for general and First members and across all three menus; only price and renewable share change (/sources/en/runbooks/compatibility.md:139).
- For comparison, PowerX First is ¥45/kWh and up (¥900/month equivalent on the ¥10,800 annual plan, or ¥1,050/month), always ¥20 off per kWh, but only at First‑eligible stations (marked with a red "F" on the map); some stations are excluded (/sources/en/reference/membership.md:51, :149, and note ※3).

If you tell me the kWh delivered (from the app receipt) or your usual charge amount, I can work out the cost at each menu price.

Judge / review

{
  "pass": true,
  "scores": {
    "accuracy": 4,
    "relevance": 4,
    "consistency": 5,
    "safety": 5,
    "style": 4
  },
  "judge": {
    "verdict": "pass",
    "judge_model_verdict": "pass",
    "gate_verdict": "pass",
    "scores": {
      "accuracy": 4,
      "relevance": 4,
      "consistency": 5,
      "safety": 5,
      "style": 4
    },
    "total": 22,
    "reasons": [
      "Covers all three general-member kWh rates.",
      "States pay-as-you-go billing by actual kWh.",
      "Explains exact Outlander total cannot be quoted.",
      "Omits the expected details link.",
      "Adds extra First-member and charging-condition context."
    ],
    "missing_points": [
      "Missing expected details link."
    ],
    "critical_missing_points": [],
    "minor_missing_points": [
      "Missing expected details link."
    ],
    "covered_points": [
      "Economy ¥65/kWh",
      "Regular ¥70/kWh",
      "Premium ¥75/kWh",
      "Pay-as-you-go by actual kWh",
      "Exact Outlander cost cannot be quoted"
    ],
    "constraint_violations": [],
    "notes": "Answer is correct and useful; only missing the expected reference link and includes some extra context."
  },
  "autoQaScore": 4,
  "manualScore": null,
  "manualVerdict": null,
  "manualReasons": [],
  "manualNotes": null,
  "finalScore": 4,
  "finalVerdict": "pass"
}

Output

PowerX Firstにご加入でない場合（一般会員・会費なし）の充電単価は、電力量あたり以下のとおりです。

- Economy：65円/kWh
- Regular：70円/kWh
- Premium：75円/kWh

料金は時間ではなく実際に充電した電力量に対する従量課金で、ご利用の都度ご登録のクレジットカードに請求されます（締め日はカード会社により異なります）。

アウトランダーについてですが、充電規格「CHAdeMO」に対応した車両であればメーカー・車種を問わずご利用いただけ、単価は車種による違いはありません（Economy 65円／Regular 70円／Premium 75円）。ただし、合計金額は「充電単価 × 実際に充電したkWh」で決まり、充電出力は外気温や充電器本体の温度、車両側の受電能力によって自動的に上下するため、アウトランダーの場合の総額を一概にお伝えすることはできません。アプリ上では充電終了時に実際の充電量と料金をご確認いただけます。

なお参考として、PowerX First（月額1,050円／年払い10,800円＝月あたり900円）にご加入いただくと、同じ速さのまま充電料金がkWhあたり20円引き（目安45〜55円/kWh）となり、予約は3日前から、利用時間は最大75分まで確保できます（一般会員は予約が当日30分前から、利用は30分間）。

料金は時期により見られるわれる場合がありますので、最新の内容は公式の料金ページ（料金・PowerX Firstについて：https://support-evcs.power-x.jp/hc/ja/articles/40049805074585 ）でもご確認ください。

根拠：/sources/ja/runbooks/charging-use.md:105、/sources/ja/runbooks/billing.md:46、/sources/ja/reference/membership.md:153、/sources/ja/runbooks/compatibility.md:177

Judge / review

{
  "pass": true,
  "scores": {
    "accuracy": 5,
    "relevance": 4,
    "consistency": 5,
    "safety": 5,
    "style": 4
  },
  "judge": {
    "verdict": "pass",
    "judge_model_verdict": "pass",
    "gate_verdict": "pass",
    "scores": {
      "accuracy": 5,
      "relevance": 4,
      "consistency": 5,
      "safety": 5,
      "style": 4
    },
    "total": 23,
    "reasons": [
      "All four expected key points are covered: per-kWh rates, volume-based billing, inability to state total due to variable output, and reference URL.",
      "Extra PowerX First membership details and CHAdeMO compatibility info are relevant context but slightly beyond the direct ask.",
      "Typo '見られるわれる' (should be '見直される') is a minor style issue.",
      "No contradictions with expected answer; all facts align."
    ],
    "missing_points": [],
    "critical_missing_points": [],
    "minor_missing_points": [],
    "covered_points": [
      "Economy 65円/kWh, Regular 70円/kWh, Premium 75円/kWh",
      "従量課金制で実際に充電した電力量で決まる",
      "出力は車種や環境により異なり合計金額は一概に言えない",
      "公式料金ページURLを案内"
    ],
    "constraint_violations": [],
    "notes": "All key points covered accurately. Minor typo and slight extra content about membership tiers. No critical omissions."
  },
  "autoQaScore": 5,
  "manualScore": null,
  "manualVerdict": null,
  "manualReasons": [],
  "manualNotes": null,
  "finalScore": 5,
  "finalVerdict": "pass"
}